Which is better: underfloor heating or radiator heating system?
You may have asked yourself this question as well. To answer it properly, we need to examine the operating mechanisms of each system along with their advantages and disadvantages (this article focuses on the technical aspects of both systems and does not include product or installation costs).
Underfloor heating is a modern heating system with a history dating back over a thousand years, used to warm indoor spaces during colder seasons. Radiator systems, on the other hand, are among the most common heating solutions used in buildings.
سیستم گرمایش از کف
In underfloor heating systems, hot water circulates through pipes embedded in the floor, transferring its heat to the concrete. The concrete then radiates this heat into the environment, creating a pleasant and uniform warmth throughout the space. In this method, the hot water is supplied by a central heating system or a package boiler and is distributed through a network of pipes using manifolds and associated control equipment. This allows heat to be delivered independently and in a controlled manner to different areas. The system is compatible with various floor coverings such as stone, ceramic, parquet, and more.
When designing and installing underfloor heating systems, factors such as the building’s heat load, pipe layout according to the architectural plan, permissible loop length and spacing, surface temperature uniformity, and placement of expansion joints play a crucial role in the system’s performance.
In underfloor heating systems, the required water temperature is lower compared to fan coil or radiator systems, typically ranging between 35°C to 50°C.
- 30% to 60% energy savings due to lower water temperature
- Provides ideal and comfortable heating
- Even heat distribution throughout the space
- Ideal for areas with high ceilings
- Suitable for residential, commercial buildings, mosques, pools, sports halls, industrial warehouses, and greenhouses
- Freedom in interior design and space-saving, as no fixed panel is required
- Clean air and no inhalation of hot air
- Clean walls and ceilings, free from soot, pollution, or darkening
- Quick drying of wet or damp floors
- Ideal for snow-melting systems in sidewalks, parking lots, ramps, and rooftops
- Compatible with various heat sources
- Minimal need for maintenance and repairs
- No rapid temperature drop during power outages due to gradual heat release
- Warm floors even in buildings above unoccupied or open spaces like parking lots or pilotis
- Easy temperature control via room thermostat
- Longer lifespan for boiler and central heating components
- Acts as insulation for the building floor
- Increased floor thickness of the building
- Added structural load (approximately 120 kg per square meter), requiring proper column design
- Longer time to heat the ambient air when the system is first turned on (to avoid damaging the flooring)
- Requires precise and engineered heating system design
- Proper installation must be done by an experienced contractor
- Difficult repairs to the building’s plumbing system
- Longer installation time (including floor insulation, pipe laying, concrete pouring, and curing to ensure concrete strength)
Radiator Heating System
In this type of heating system, water is heated to approximately 60 to 80 degrees Celsius by a boiler or a central heating unit and then circulated through pipes to radiator panels (typically made of steel, aluminum, etc.) located inside the building. These heated panels warm the surrounding air through convection (heat transfer by air movement). As the warm air rises, cooler air takes its place, and this cycle gradually heats the room.
Due to the individual nature of radiator panels, the radiator heating system often does not provide uniform heat distribution and typically consumes more energy to adequately warm the entire home.
- Short heating time required to warm the house
- Easy installation and setup
- Temperature control capability via the heating unit (boiler)
- Radiators can be installed after the building is completed by the final owner
- Widely used and easily accessible
- Easy installation for beginners and non-experts
- Ability to replace and repair at any time
- High availability of installers and technicians
- Relatively short lifespan
- Occupies part of the home’s space due to radiator panels
- Uneven heat distribution in the space
- Darkening and discoloration of walls and curtains over time
- Possibility of radiator leakage
- Reduced system efficiency in large areas, leading to cold spots
- Potential for malfunction and scaling in radiator components
- High wear and frequent breakdowns
- High fuel consumption
- Annual maintenance and repair costs
- Discoloration and loss of aesthetic appeal of radiator panels after years of use
- Need to stay close to or touch the radiator to feel warm
Leave a Reply